Helicopter Musings on Gold and Silver

Welcome to the Precious Metals Bug Forums

Welcome to the PMBug forums - a community supported watering hole for folks interested in gold, silver, precious metals, sound money, investing, market and economic news, central bank monetary policies, politics and more.

Register a free account to join the discussions. When you register an account and log in, you may enjoy additional benefits including access to market data/charts and additional members only rooms (including one for trade/barter with the community).

pmbug

Your Host
Administrator
Benefactor
Messages
22,186
Reaction score
9,418
Points
268
Location
Texas

Helicopter Musings on Gold and Silver​


Gold

There are several concurrent things happening that lead me to think that LBMA gold free float vault stock might be more constrained than anyone thinks (at least - I'm not seeing anyone talk about it):

> The premium for SGE gold to LBMA gold has been increasing over the last few days. Looks like China's demand for gold is growing.

> The IBJA spot discount to LBMA spot is collapsing while MCX futures gold vault stock is on the rise over the last few days. It looks like Indian gold demand is growing while they are also buying gold again. I expect we'll learn later that Indian gold imports have surged here in late September.

> COMEX Exchange For Physical (EFP) spread went deeply negative (providing bullion banks a profit arbitrage for taking delivery of COMEX gold and shipping it to London to sell in the LBMA OTC market) and at the same time the COMEX delisted "Enhanced Delivery" gold vault stock to the tune of 4M ozt. This while delivery requests against the September contract have been consistently strong over the last few days. It looks to me like fallout from physical demand from India buying gold (either directly from the COMEX or indirectly via the LBMA and bullion banks need to shore up London vault stock with COMEX gold).

> GLD (and presumably most other gold ETFs, though I'm not watching them daily) vault stock has been growing with large inflows over the last week. That directly pressures the LBMA free float vault stock.

I'm guessing the COMEX's 4M ozt "Enhanced Delivery" vault stock is being used to cover some supply stress. I don't expect we get an transparency on it though.

Silver

Silver looks a lot more calm compared to gold at the moment and that's somewhat surprising as silver is usually the volatile metal. However, there are some things I'm paying attention to:

> SGE spot premium to LBMA has remained consistently high between $8 and $9 per ozt. Demand seems steady and strong.

> IBJA spot + MCX futures are both maintaining a premium to LBMA spot even after discounting the 15% import duty. At the same time, MCX silver (KG) vault stock is back on the rise indicating that India is buying and importing silver. Physical demand in India remains strong.

> In the last three days, COMEX silver withdrawals slowed down but prior to that, were very heavy. The 5 DMA of deposits and withdrawals is currently negative (a withdrawal rate). Will the drain pick up again as we head into October (a heavy demand month for silver)?

> SLV (and most other ETFs) has increased vault stock which directly pressures LBMA free float. The 1mo lease rate has responded rising from moderately negative back to positive or near zero in the last few days.

Looks to me like a pot of water that is simmering but not at a boil yet. Yet.
 
Helicopter musings on gold and silver

Gold

SGE (China spot) premium to LBMA spot has been slowly shrinking over the last few days while SHFE (China futures) has waffled between premium and discount to SGE price. As they don't publish gold vault stock numbers, it unclear what the price action is signaling.

On the other hand, India's MCX futures have exploded to a huge premium over LBMA spot even as the MCX gold (KG) vault is adding vault stock every day consistently for the last week. IBJA (Indian spot) PM fix at one point jumped to a huge premium over LBMA spot but has since tracked just under it (a slight discount). These premiums/discounts are when comparing apples to apples - Indian prices ex 15% import duties. Looks like demand for gold in India is running hot.

Meanwhile the COMEX has not had any deposits to the gold vaults since Oct 1. The drain rate appears to be accelerating.

We won't get any sunshine on the LBMA vault situation for several weeks (months if you want customs import/export data to double check the LBMA's numbers). It sure seems like the volume of metal flowing around is increasing. I can only imagine how busy that poor lorry is in the LBMA bullion yard.

GLD (and presumably the other London vaulted gold ETFs though I haven't checked them since the start of the month) are holding the line on their vault stock in spite of the monkey hammers to the paper prices. Looks like investors aren't selling the dips. Looks like the LBMA's slushy (fund) machines are out of order.


Silver

Unlike with gold, SGE/SHFE silver premiums to LBMA spot have remained pretty consistent. SHFE vault stock is draining heavily over the last week however. I won't be surprised if we learn next week that the SGE vault has also drained significantly this week (their reporting is delayed). The China premiums to LBMA spot should be sufficient for silver to flow from London to China (or Hong Kong), so I'm not sure why the China vaults are draining so heavily presently. I can only conclude that they are not importing enough to meet the demand.

India appears to be running hot with silver demand as the MCX futures and IBJA spot are both running steady premiums to LBMA spot (AFTER subtracting the 15% import duty). The MCX silver (KG) vault has seen some heavy outflows in the last few days and the 5 day moving average run rate is down to 41 business days of vault stock left (less than 3 months) at the current 5 DMA withdrawal rate. It's clear that they are not importing enough silver to meet domestic demand. The government's response has been to try and restrict market access to ETFs (which would buy physical silver in accordance with market demand). I suspect that's not going to solve the problem.

The COMEX continues to report heavy deposits and withdrawals. Over the last few weeks, on a given day, anywhere from 2M to 5M ozt of silver is flowing in and out of the COMEX vaults. I'm guessing bullion banks are having to draw down on the USA's shadow inventory to balance COMEX withdrawals and maintain a safe COMEX vault stock operating cushion. Withdrawals are running >80% of Oct26 contract delivery requests. It rarely runs that high and when it has done so in the past, it's been to support the LBMA in meeting heavy demand.

Between JPM's mid-month 3M ozt NYC to London silver vault stock swap and yesterday's massive 4.4M ozt addition, SLV's London vault has grown massively since the start of the month. That's a huge bite out of the LBMA's free float vault stock. I'm assuming the other London vaulted silver ETFs/ETPs are also following SLV's lead, but I haven't checked them since the start of the month.

After the close yesterday, the Exchange For Physical (EFP) spread (COMEX futures - LBMA spot) for the COMEX Oct26 contract dropped to a large -$0.59. The last time it is was this deeply negative was early March and the COMEX was draining vault stock heavily. I'm wondering if we're going to see some heavy COMEX withdrawals tomorrow or next week as we get the activity reports for yesterday and today.

All signs are pointing to heavy demand for physical silver from the LBMA. While waiting for confirmation from LBMA and customs data in the coming weeks and months, I'm hoping to see some confirmation with the 1 month silver lease rate in the coming days. Very exciting.
 
Helicopter Musings on Gold and Silver

It's been a while since I posted one of these. It looks to me like there are a strong rip currents happening right now though - price action is not reflecting underlying vault flows.

Gold

India's MCX exchange has been running a large >$30/ozt premium to LBMA spot even after discounting the 15% Indian import duty for the last couple of weeks. Meanwhile, MCX gold vault stock (for the KG contract used by Indian industry) has been rising (indirectly indicating that India is importing gold in quantity). It is up ~10% over the last two weeks. News from India indicates that retail demand for Diwali has been very strong (over 10% more than last year). This morning, the IBJA PM fix (Indian spot) (excluding import duty) surged to a ~$14 premium over LBMA spot. Diwali may have ended, but India still has to make up for 3 months of lost imports from May-July as a result of government import duties and restrictions. It appears that demand is still running hot.

I don't get vault flow data for China's SGE or SHFE markets, but SGE/SHFE gold prices have remained in a consistent premium to LBMA spot. Media reports says that China is buying/importing record amounts of gold lately. Their main retail gold market was apparently swarming with shoppers during a holiday recently. It certainly seems like all indications are supportive of gold demand in China remaining strong.

Some European nations have made news in recent weeks regarding efforts to repatriate their gold from NYC. The Netherlands' efforts were particularly curious as they did a partial physical delivery and a partial "sell NYC stock, buy London replacement" swap. It raised several questions in my mind:

"Why do it for a partial repatriation? If it was more cost effective to sell/repurchase, why didn't they do that for all of it? If it was not cost effective, why did they do it at all? Assuming the last case was correct, did the Fed just not have the physical gold to deliver?"

While global demand is running hot and the Fed may not have market acceptable gold in the vaults, the West's free float vault stock (COMEX + LBMA less Bank of England and ETFs/ETPs) shrunk 2 metric tons in October. The West's pile of gold is shrinking while the East races to build gold trading hubs in Hong Kong and Singapore to challenge London for market dominance.

"Buckle up."

Silver

In late October, it was reported that India had issued permits for importing 6,500 metric tons of silver through the next six months (through April). India's MCX exchange's silver KG vault's 5 day moving average flipped from vault stock drain to vault stock gain at the start of November. Since the start of the month, the MCX silver KG vault has added ~42 metric tons. It certainly seems like India has started to process some of that 6,500 tonnes allotment. Meanwhile, both the MCX silver KG futures and IBJA spot prices have maintained premiums to LBMA spot even after discounting India's 15% import duty. As with gold, Diwali may have ended, but India still has to make up for 3 months of lost imports from May-July as a result of government import duties and restrictions. It appears that demand is still running hot.

In China, the SHFE futures exchange has drained ~10% (~4M ozt) of its vault stock since the start of October. The SGE has posted two consecutive weeks of outflows encompassing >3.3M ozt or >10% of its late October vault stock. China is supposedly restricting silver exports, so presumably, these vault drains represent domestic demand and not sales to India, though customs import/export data will confirm or deny that when it becomes available. In the meantime, SHFE/SGE prices for silver remain at a premium to global markets (both LBMA & India). It looks to me like China is not importing sufficient quantities of silver to meet domestic demand.

The London vault stock of silver ETFs increased in October thanks to heavy lifting from SLV. The LBMA's free float silver vault stock took a huge hit in October. How long can the USA's shadow inventory continue to support the LBMA in satisfying global demand? I think we find out in the months ahead.
 
Helicopter Musings on Gold and Silver Nov 17

It's been a week since I posted one of these. Gold and silver prices are swirling around the toilets as the markets flush them. What's happening beneath the price action though?

Gold

India:

MCX exchange posted strong inflows for the gold kilogram vault which increased >30% over the last week.
Indian retail claims strong buying demand per media reports.
Since Nov 17 (3 days now), IBJA spot price has been running at a premium to MCX futures.
Since Nov 17, IBJA spot price (*excluding* 15% import duty) has been running at a huge premium to LBMA spot.

It would seem that India was importing gold last week, but it's still not sufficient to meet the current demand for immediate delivery gold.

China's SGE market does not publish gold vault stock figures. I've just started to watch the SHFE gold vault stock and it has been increasing, but it seems to be updated weekly and not daily. SGE/SHFE price premiums to LBMA spot have contracted a bit from last week, but remain >$6/ozt as of this morning. It looks to me like China has been importing enough gold to balance domestic demand over the last week.

The COMEX gold vault has been alternating between net outflow and net inflow for the last few days. The 5 day moving average for COMEX gold vault stock flipped from outflow to inflow this past week. The withdrawals have not been as consistent as the past few weeks. It seems curious to me as I would expect that India would be scarfing up the "cheap" gold.

GLD gold vault stock has fluctuated a little up and down, but essentially held ground (up slightly) over the last week. The LBMA doesn't publish daily or weekly vault stock updates, so we are left to wonder what is happening in their vaults.

Silver

India:

MCX exchange went from strong inflows last week to weak inflows to outflows for silver kilogram vault this week. The 5 day moving average has shrunk from >100K ozt/day last week to ~11K ozt/day as of this morning.
Indian retail claims strong buying demand per media reports.
MCX & IBJA prices (excluding 15% import duty) have remained at a fairly consistent premium to LBMA spot at >$1 all week.
India reportedly imported 1,000 tonnes silver in October. 5,500 tonnes to go by April.

It looks to me like either Indian imports are waning, or domestic demand is increasing. Indian market prices aren't giving us much of a signal/clue as to why the MCX vault inflows have dried up.

China:

SHFE silver vault down 1.5M ozt (46.6t) over the last week.
SGE (spot) has been flip flopping from discount to premium versus SHFE December futures for the last few days (it's a premium this morning).
SGE & SHFE premiums to LBMA spot have slowly declined over the last week from ~$6/ozt to ~$5/ozt.

We don't get SGE silver vault stock data until next week, but from what we can see right now, it looks to me like a mixed picture. SGE spot running a premium to SHFE Dec futures would seem to indicate that immediate delivery is in demand, but falling premiums to LBMA spot indicate that there is sufficient imports/free float vault stock to satisfy the demand.

Deposits to the COMEX silver vaults have picked up over the last week, but withdrawals have also continued to run hot. Overall, the net result is a steady outflow with the 5 day moving average of net inflow/outflow maintaining a >400K ozt/day net outflow. Actual withdrawals are running >80% of delivery requests so far in November (that's high, but not historic).

In spite of the consistent COMEX silver vault drain, COMEX Nov & Dec contracts are running at a discount to LBMA spot. It seems that demand for LBMA silver is running hotter than COMEX future delivery silver. Maybe that's why SLV has shed nearly 5M ozt (~150t) of silver over the last two days after holding steady for the previous week plus.

Overall, it looks to me like Indian demand is driving COMEX + LBMA vault drain, but we don't have sufficient transparency to really see the full picture.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…