
Monday, the independent website Consortium News filed suit against the United States of America and Newsguard Technologies. The complaint targeting both the government and a private media ratings service is an important one, putting the censorship-by-proxy system on trial.
On September 7, 2021, the U.S. Department of Defense gave an award of $749,387 to Newsguard Technologies, a private service that scores media outlets on “reliability” and “trust.” According to the suit, roughly 40,000 subscribers buy Newsguard subscriptions, getting in return a system of “Nutrition Labels” supposedly emphasizing “safe” content. Importantly, Newsguard’s customers include universities and libraries, whose users are presented with labels warning you that CBS is great and Tucker Carlson is dangerous:
...
More (long):

Newsguard Case Highlights the Pentagon's Censorship End-Around
The Consortium News lawsuit against a private news rating system lays out how the government can suppress speech by proxy

The complaint highlights NewsGuard’s association with the Pentagon’s Cyber Command. In 2021, the Pentagon awarded a contract to NewsGuard to create a system known as “misinformation fingerprints”. This system was designed to track various types of misinformation online. The claim suggests that NewsGuard, with support from the U.S. government, sought to suppress Consortium’s critiques of U.S. foreign policy, particularly regarding Russia, Ukraine, and the Middle East.
Consortium states that NewsGuard, through its Pentagon contract, tried to influence news organizations to modify their perspectives, leading to potential censorship. “The First Amendment rights of all American media are threatened by this arrangement with the Defense Department to defame and abridge the speech of U.S. media groups,” commented Bruce Afran, the lawyer representing Consortium News.
...
The lawsuit is registered as Consortium For Independent Journalism vs. The United States of America and NewsGuard Technologies, Docket No: 23-cv-07088 in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.

Consortium News Files Lawsuit Against NewsGuard and U.S. Government Over Alleged Censorship
Consortium News, a website concentrating on foreign policy, is taking legal action against NewsGuard and the U.S. government.
