Kitco Bid/Ask BS

jd1123

Fly on the Wall
Messages
36
Reaction score
0
Points
0
What's with the kitco bid/ask on silver? I'm looking at a live feed of futures trades and their bid/ask seems to be last trade (bid) / last trade +0.1 (ask). What is this nonesense?

Apologies if this has been brought up before.
 

swissaustrian

Yellow Jacket
Messages
2,053
Reaction score
0
Points
0
http://www.kitcosilver.com/

I'm watching bloomberg right now - a live feed of all trades. Doubt it's illiquidity as the futures are trading. Call me nuts, but I think it's a way of getting another 10 cent out of you without you knowing it.
Second guessing: This could very well be an algo who is sucking these 10c off each trade...

See an example for that "trading model" (buying at the ask and selling at the bid) here:
http://www.nanex.net/aqck2/3525.html
 

jd1123

Fly on the Wall
Messages
36
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Second guessing: This could very well be an algo who is sucking these 10c off each trade...

See an example for that "trading model" (buying at the ask and selling at the bid) here:
http://www.nanex.net/aqck2/3525.html
True - but I don't think this is it either. I called Kitco and asked where they get the bid ask from. They said Reuters. This is inconsistent with what I was looking at on Bloomberg. My Bloomberg terminal does not post bid and offer prices, just the last trade.

I'm a commodity trader so I look at this type of stuff all day long. The "bid" price they were quoting was simply the last trade on the exchange for the front silver contract. The "ask" price was simply this plus 10 cents.

My experience is that bid/ask spreads in a market with many participants are rarely always uniformly spaced in time. For instance, you have many buyers and sellers competing for a price. Dealers are constantly posting their 2-ways which usually are uniform. At some point or another an axed buyer or seller will "cut" a dealer's market, robot or not.

I find it hard to believe that after trading for size on a bid, that the bid stays put. Usually, when dealing, if you get done at your bid, and your two-way is 10 cents wide, you would make it 10 cents wide around the last trade price. I.e, you bid 29.97 for 100 lots and you get them, your price is now 29.92/30.02. This was not happening on kitco's site.

It also makes sense, given the current metals environment, that they have many more buyers than sellers. Furthermore, another PM website (Liberty coin and precious metals) was reporting a different, tighter and more reasonable bid/ask at the same time (priced around the last trade).

I guess, at the very least, this will bring attention to the issue. Frankly, I DO NOT TRUST THE INFO POSTED ON KITCO.

EDIT: The other alternative is that Reuters has crap information. This would not be out of the question either. It does not change my stance on not trusting the bid/ask spreads on Kitco though...
 
Last edited:

jd1123

Fly on the Wall
Messages
36
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Okay - it seems to have gotten worse. I've been following it since I started this thread.


During the day - same deal - kitco bid was last trade on COMEX. Ask was 10 cents above.

Last night - the kitco bid/ask seemed in line with what I saw on Bloomberg and Liberty's website.

Now - the bid price is 0.01 ABOVE the last trade on the COMEX. The ask is still 10 cents above the bid in all cases.

Maybe I'm missing something here. I was told that the spot price = front month futures price. Is this true?
 
Top