ChatGPT: Tax turnover

Highlights thread as a discussion with ChatGPT

Welcome to the Precious Metals Bug Forums

Welcome to the PMBug forums - a watering hole for folks interested in gold, silver, precious metals, sound money, investing, market and economic news, central bank monetary policies, politics and more. You can visit the forum page to see the list of forum nodes (categories/rooms) for topics.

Why not register an account and join the discussions? When you register an account and log in, you may enjoy additional benefits including no Google ads, market data/charts, access to trade/barter with the community and much more. Registering an account is free - you have nothing to lose!

Uglytruth

Fly on the Wall
Messages
73
Reaction score
41
Points
98
Must working people pay 25% income tax. Workers then pay 8% tax on taxable items when purchased. There are also other taxes, things like state tax, city tax, property tax, drivers license, license plates, fishing license, gasoline tax, dining out, clothing, taxes on investment income, etc.....

What is the average real total tax paid if a person has minimal deductions?
 
To calculate the average real total tax paid by a person with minimal deductions, we need to consider all the taxes mentioned in your post along with the given income tax and sales tax rates. Let's break down the calculation step by step:

1. **Income Tax**: The person pays 25% income tax on their earnings.
2. **Sales Tax**: The person pays 8% tax on taxable items when purchased.
3. **Other Taxes**: We will assume some average values for the other taxes mentioned, as they can vary widely depending on location, income level, and individual circumstances. Let's consider an approximate breakdown for other taxes:

- State Tax: Let's assume an average of 5%.
- City Tax: Let's estimate 1%.
- Property Tax: Let's consider an average of 1%.
- Driver's License: Let's include an average fee of $50 annually.
- License Plates: Let's estimate an average of $50 annually.
- Fishing License: Let's assume an average fee of $30 annually.
- Gasoline Tax: Let's assume an average of 20 cents per gallon.
- Dining Out: Let's include an average of 7% on dining expenses.
- Clothing: Let's include an average of 5% on clothing purchases.
- Taxes on Investment Income: Let's include an average of 15%.
- Other Taxes & Fees: Let's consider an additional 3%.

Now, let's calculate the total average tax paid as a percentage of income:

Total tax rate = Income tax rate + Sales tax rate + State tax rate + City tax rate + Property tax rate + (Driver's License cost + License Plates cost + Fishing License cost) / Income + (Gasoline Tax rate * Average gallons consumed annually * Price per gallon) / Income + (Dining Out tax rate + Clothing tax rate + Taxes on Investment Income rate + Other Taxes & Fees rate) / Income

Plug in the values mentioned above and calculate the average total tax paid as a percentage of income. This will provide you with an approximate average real total tax paid by a person with minimal deductions.
 
Plug in the values mentioned above and calculate the average total tax paid as a percentage of income. This will provide you with an approximate average real total tax paid by a person with minimal deductions.
Please do it for a person with $50,000 wage income and $1000 investment income.

Use 8% in your interest calculations and gas tax at $0.385
 
Please do it for a person with $50,000 wage income and $1000 investment income.

Use 8% in your interest calculations and gas tax at $0.385
Let's calculate the average total tax paid by a person with a $50,000 wage income and $1,000 investment income, considering the provided tax rates for income tax, sales tax, and other taxes:

1. **Income Tax**: $50,000 * 25% = $12,500
2. **Sales Tax**: Assume the person spends a portion of their income on taxable items. Let's estimate it at 10% of their income:
Sales Tax = $50,000 * 10% * 8% = $400
3. **Other Taxes**:
- State Tax: $50,000 * 5% = $2,500
- City Tax: $50,000 * 1% = $500
- Property Tax: $50,000 * 1% = $500
- Driver's License: $50
- License Plates: $50
- Fishing License: $30
- Gasoline Tax: Assuming average consumption is 500 gallons per year, Gasoline Tax = 500 gallons * $0.385/gallon = $192.50
- Dining Out Tax: $50,000 * 7% = $3,500
- Clothing Tax: $50,000 * 5% = $2,500
- Taxes on Investment Income: $1,000 * 15% = $150
- Other Taxes & Fees: $50,000 * 3% = $1,500

Adding all these amounts together:

Total Tax Paid = Income Tax + Sales Tax + State Tax + City Tax + Property Tax + Driver's License + License Plates + Fishing License + Gasoline Tax + Dining Out Tax + Clothing Tax + Taxes on Investment Income + Other Taxes & Fees

Total Tax Paid = $12,500 + $400 + $2,500 + $500 + $500 + $50 + $50 + $30 + $192.50 + $3,500 + $2,500 + $150 + $1,500
Total Tax Paid = $23,872.50

To find the average total tax paid as a percentage of income:

Average Total Tax Rate = Total Tax Paid / (Wage Income + Investment Income)
Average Total Tax Rate = $23,872.50 / ($50,000 + $1,000)
Average Total Tax Rate = $23,872.50 / $51,000
Average Total Tax Rate ≈ 46.91%

Therefore, the average real total tax paid by a person with a $50,000 wage income and $1,000 investment income, with the provided tax rates and assumptions, is approximately 46.91% of their total income.
 
Therefore, the average real total tax paid by a person with a $50,000 wage income and $1,000 investment income, with the provided tax rates and assumptions, is approximately 46.91% of their total income.
Is that a reasonable amount?
 
Is that a reasonable amount?
Whether a total tax rate of approximately 46.91% on a $50,000 wage income and $1,000 investment income is reasonable can vary depending on various factors such as location, tax laws, cost of living, individual circumstances, and personal opinions.

In general, a total tax rate approaching 50% may seem high to individuals, especially if they feel that a significant portion of their income is going towards various taxes and fees. It's important to consider the services and benefits provided by the government in return for these taxes, such as infrastructure, healthcare, education, social services, and more.

However, what constitutes a "reasonable" amount of tax is subjective and can vary based on personal beliefs and priorities. Some may argue that higher taxes are necessary to fund essential public services, while others may feel that lower taxes promote economic growth and individual financial freedom.

Ultimately, the assessment of whether a tax rate is reasonable is highly individual and may vary based on one's perspective, financial situation, and societal values. It's important for individuals to stay informed about tax laws, advocate for changes if needed, and consider consulting with tax professionals for personalized advice.
 
Is a nearly 50% tax rate what the nations Founders had in mind when they started this nation?
 
Is a nearly 50% tax rate what the nations Founders had in mind when they started this nation?

Joe, if you are asking chatbot this question you have to quote chatbot first.
 
Joe, if you are asking chatbot this question you have to quote chatbot first.
It was a rhetorical question, because everyone reading this already knows that the answer is no.

The dumb chatbot would say that depending on point of view that it could be.

However, the gov needs the money for all the shit it says it wants to do for people.

Ie: it defaults to a lib/progressive/commie position on everything.
 
Joe, if you are asking chatbot this question you have to quote chatbot first.
I just noticed that didn't work in this other thread.

He quoted it and asked a question. Still no response. Or did his question break chatgpt?
 
I just noticed that didn't work in this other thread.

He quoted it and asked a question. Still no response. Or did his question break chatgpt?

Went to the thread and played around with the question.
 
Back
Top Bottom